Fenerty starts the poem off
with his love for the tree, thus nature. He
then makes the tree out to be a prophet, or
a guardian of nature. Then he questions what
all must have past during its life time (How
many a changeful scene has fled, since first
thy vernal cloak was spread, in this lone forest
wild). This is where he starts talking about
humanity. He even mentions the decline of Spain.
Fenerty has another poem called the
Decline
of Spain. The poem was never dated, and
is difficult to get an idea when it was written,
but it could have be written around the same
time as Betual Nigra (1854). Henry Thomas Buckle,
in his The History of Civilization in England
(Volume two), mentions the decline of Spain.
Fenerty did read this volume (mentioned in his
Essay on Progress), but the second volume appeared
in 1861. It's possible that Fenerty wrote The
Decline of Spain poem around the same time as
EOP. In Betula Nigra, Fenerty is basically wondering
for the tree (and if the tree could talk, Fenerty
would be asking it questions). But he also wants
to make it known that man and nature, though
two of the same kind, their differences are
due to man’s ignorance (when he states
the American Maxim – make war on the wilderness).
That’s all man sees of nature –
not its beauty, or a vehicle to wonderment,
but rather its grounds to set the battlefield.
In other words, we simply ignore it. Towards
the end, one gets the feeling that his purpose
of the poem was to use the life of the tree
to display human deeds (good or bad). The poem
doesn't go in depth on human achievement, but
it does create an apparent contrast between
the serenity of nature and the strife of man
– where both man and tree are related
and share a history together, yet man chooses
to ignore it, being too consumed by his own
indifferences.